RateMyDick.ai

Dick in a Box by The Lonely Island feat. Justin Timberlake (2006)

Incredibad · 2:38

An Emmy-winning three-step gift-wrapping tutorial, and the only song on this list with a craft component.

Incredibad (Deluxe Version) — The Lonely Island feat. Justin Timberlake, cover art
Official video · 2:52
Official video · Saturday Night Live · via YouTube · poster: cover art, Incredibad (Deluxe Version) (2009) · ℗ 2009 Universal Republic Records, a division of UMG Recordings, Inc. · via Apple Music / iTunes · Watch on YouTube ↗
The Lonely Island, photo
Photo · The Lonely Island · UPROXX · CC BY 3.0 · via Wikimedia Commons
Dick in a Box video, frame at 50%
Frame at 50% · Saturday Night Live · via YouTube
Dick in a Box video, frame at 75%
Frame at 75% · Saturday Night Live · via YouTube
1 / 4 · Video

Our ranking

#1of 75
Most about a dick
1
Explicit words · distinct
Repetitions, density and the innuendo countAll the numbers ↓
The internet's verdict

Is it any good?

Anonymous. One vote per song, and you see the result after you vote.

What the title means

Literal. The gift is a box with a hole cut in the bottom, and the three steps are how you make one. Wrapping paper is optional.

What the song is actually about

It aired as a Saturday Night Live Digital Short in December 2006, and by the following Monday it was the most-watched thing on the internet. Andy Samberg and Justin Timberlake, in matching silk shirts and Color Me Badd facial hair, perform a pitch-perfect parody of mid-nineties slow-jam R&B in which the romantic gesture on offer is exactly what the title says. The song walks the listener through three steps, and the third step is the punchline every time.

Two things made it more than a sketch. The production is genuinely good, and Timberlake sang it straight, which is why it holds up as a record and not just a clip. And it won: the Creative Arts Emmy for Outstanding Original Music and Lyrics in 2007, meaning the Television Academy formally recognised a song about a dick in a box as the year's best piece of television songwriting, in a ceremony attended by adults. NBC put the unbleeped version online, which at the time was itself news.

Its afterlife is the three steps, which nearly everyone under fifty can recite. It turned the Lonely Island into a band with a record deal, made the Digital Short an institution, and comes back every December as the gift idea nobody should take. It is the most recognised modern song on this subject, and the only one your parents can sing, unfortunately.

The line

“my dick in a box”

Where it ranks, and why

Composite read
99PCTLRank
8.9COMPOSITE · /10◇ #1 of 75
67PCTLExplicit words
Most explicit · #16 of 37DocumentedSays the word
Highest readsagainst all 75
Score8.999th
Recognition995th
Topicality1090th
Lowest readsagainst all 75
Innuendo05th
Score8.999th
Topicality1090th
Recognition995th
Reach6.273rd
YouTube views20.7M74th
Like rate11.077th
Explicit words167th
Repetitions1675th
Innuendo05th
Words per minute0.479th
Length2:3815th
Percentile against all 75 songs · the shaded band is the middle half · judged scores are editorial, counts never enter a score

On RMD's list it sits at #1 of 75 with a composite of 8.9 — topicality 10 (×0.6), reach 6.2 (×0.25, log-scaled) and recognition 9 (×0.15). On the explicit list it is #16 of 37, on 1 distinct explicit word at 0.4 per minute, with the main hook repeated 16×. The innuendo figure (0) is editorial and never enters either number. Read the methodology →

Lyrics ↗We don't host lyrics — we explain them.Facts checked 2026-10-05

Asked

Who sang Dick in a Box?
Andy Samberg and Justin Timberlake, as a Saturday Night Live Digital Short in December 2006.
Did Dick in a Box win an Emmy?
Yes: Outstanding Original Music and Lyrics, 2007.
What are the three steps?
Cut the hole, put it in, let her open the box.
How do we know it's about a dick?
Documented. The premise is the lyric; the Emmy and the unbleeped online release are on Wikipedia.en.wikipedia.org ↗

Rated the songs. Now rate the subject.

Now you know about Dick in a Box, it's time to learn more about yourself.

Analyze mine

Images are shown to identify the recording and illustrate the commentary. Rights holders: email support@ratewithai.co and we will remove an image promptly.