RateMyDick.ai

John Holmes (una vita per il cinema) by Elio e le Storie Tese (1989)

Elio samaga hukapan kariyana turu · 4:09

Italy's defining comedy band wrote a biography of the most famous penis in film history and made it all up, except the measurements.

Elio Samaga Hukapan Kariyana Turu — Elio e le Storie Tese, cover art
Audio · 4:09
Audio · Giuseppe Busu · via YouTube · poster: cover art, Elio Samaga Hukapan Kariyana Turu (1989) · ℗ 1989 Psycho · via Apple Music / iTunes · Watch on YouTube ↗
Elio e le Storie Tese, photo
Photo · Elio e le Storie Tese · nicola abbiuso · CC BY 2.0 · via Wikimedia Commons
1 / 2 · Audio

Our ranking

#57of 75
Most about a dick
1
Explicit words · distinct
Repetitions, density and the innuendo countAll the numbers ↓
The internet's verdict

Is it any good?

Anonymous. One vote per song, and you see the result after you vote.

What the title means

"John Holmes, a life for the cinema." Holmes was the porn actor famous for one measurement; the song tells invented stories about him in the tone of a state funeral, and the band have called it the true invented story of the most beloved porn star.

What the song is actually about

Elio e le Storie Tese wrote John Holmes in the early 1980's, at the height of Holmes's fame, and played it live from 1987 before putting it on their 1989 debut album, Elio samaga hukapan kariyana turu. The song is a mock-hagiography: episodes from a life that never happened, sung with the solemnity of a concert programme. The joke is that the only true thing about the subject is the thing nobody mentions, and the song mentions nothing else.

The band have said it was written as a criticism of the hard-core industry of the period, which turned performers of dubious talent into idols, and it is the clearest early example of what made them Italy's great comedy band: musicianship far better than the joke requires, and a joke better than it needs to be. It has been in the live set for nearly forty years, longer than most of the careers it satirises.

Its afterlife is as the Italian size entry. Where Mickey Avalon compares and Lil Dicky despairs, Elio canonises: Holmes is treated as a saint of a church that has only one relic. It is the band's phallic standard and the one song on this list where the subject is a specific, named, famous example of the organ, with a filmography.

The line

“John Holmes, una vita per il cinema”
John Holmes, a life for the cinema

Where it ranks, and why

Composite read
25PCTLRank
6.0COMPOSITE �· /10◇ #57 of 75
67PCTLExplicit words
Most explicit · #36 of 37DocumentedAbout size
Highest readsagainst all 75
Explicit words167th
Words per minute0.254th
Topicality850th
Lowest readsagainst all 75
YouTube views161k7th
Reach2.47th
Recognition419th
Score6.023rd
Topicality850th
Recognition419th
Reach2.47th
YouTube views161k7th
Like rate6.838th
Explicit words167th
Repetitions836th
Innuendo445th
Words per minute0.254th
Length4:0981st
Percentile against all 75 songs · the shaded band is the middle half · judged scores are editorial, counts never enter a score

On RMD's list it sits at #57 of 75 with a composite of 6 — topicality 8 (×0.6), reach 2.4 (×0.25, log-scaled) and recognition 4 (×0.15). On the explicit list it is #36 of 37, on 1 distinct explicit word at 0.2 per minute, with the main hook repeated 8×. The innuendo figure (4) is editorial and never enters either number. Read the methodology →

Lyrics ↗We don't host lyrics — we explain them.Facts checked 2026-10-05

Asked

What is John Holmes by Elio e le Storie Tese about?
Invented episodes from the life of the porn actor John Holmes, sung as a tribute and meant as satire of the industry that made him an idol.
When was it released?
Played live from 1987 and on the band's 1989 debut album.
Is any of it true?
By the band's own account, none of the stories; the subject's one famous attribute is the only fact.
How do we know it's about a dick?
Documented. The subject and the band's own description are on Italian Wikipedia's entry for the song.it.wikipedia.org ↗en.wikipedia.org ↗

Rated the songs. Now rate the subject.

Now you know about John Holmes (una vita per il cinema), it's time to learn more about yourself.

Analyze mine

Images are shown to identify the recording and illustrate the commentary. Rights holders: email support@ratewithai.co and we will remove an image promptly.